🧁 BakingSwaps

Instant ingredient substitutions

Best Vanilla Extract Substitutes for Baking

Out of vanilla extract? These substitutes keep your baked goods fragrant and flavorful.

1. Vanilla Bean Paste

Replace 1:1

Richer vanilla flavor with visible bean specks — actually better than extract.

Shop on Amazon →

2. Vanilla Powder

Replace 1:1

Alcohol-free option, great for dry mixes.

Shop on Amazon →

3. Maple Syrup

Replace 1:1

Adds subtle maple flavor — great in cookies and pancakes.

Shop on Amazon →

← Try our AI substitution tool