Question 1

Can I use Regular Milk (reduced) as a substitute?

Accepted Answer

Simmer 2¼ cups milk until reduced to 1 cup. Exact substitute, just takes 20 minutes.

Question 2

Can I use Half and Half as a substitute?

Accepted Answer

Replace 1:1. No cooking needed — similar fat content.

Question 3

Can I use Coconut Milk as a substitute?

Accepted Answer

Replace 1:1. Dairy-free option — adds subtle coconut flavor.

Best Evaporated Milk Substitutes for Baking

1. Regular Milk (reduced)